Supermarkets in Shelter Island, New York The most complete information about Supermarkets in Shelter Island, New York: Addresses, phone numbers, reviews and other information. All stores Clothing Department Furniture Home goods Liquor Supermarket All supermarkets in Shelter Island Elli's Country Store Liquor Supermarket Closed now Until 06:30 am 35 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Get Directions Contacts Write a review