Liquor stores in Shelter Island, New York The most complete information about Liquor stores in Shelter Island, New York: Addresses, phone numbers, reviews and other information. All stores Clothing Department Furniture Home goods Liquor Supermarket All liquor stores in Shelter Island Dandy Liquors Liquor 43 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Get Directions Contacts Write a review Elli's Country Store Liquor Supermarket Closed now Until 06:30 am 35 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964 Get Directions Contacts Write a review ✗ Facebook Google Plus Twitter